January 2, 2024

VAT Victory: Unraveling ECJ Case C-385/09 and Securing Your Refund Rights

In the aforementioned legal dispute, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) delivered a precedent-setting ruling with far-reaching implications for entities engaged in Value Added Tax (VAT) transactions. The focal point of the case was Nidera Handelscompagnie, a Dutch company involved in international trade, specifically the acquisition of wheat from Lithuanian suppliers. The crux of the matter was the company's ability to claim a VAT refund despite an incomplete VAT identification process.

The ECJ, after careful consideration, unequivocally determined that Nidera Handelscompagnie had the right to reclaim VAT paid in a foreign jurisdiction for business-related purchases. This landmark decision is of paramount importance, particularly for businesses navigating the intricate terrain of VAT registration, especially when engaged in transactions preceding the acquisition of an active VAT number.

In this particular instance, the Dutch company procured goods for business purposes, specifically wheat from Lithuanian suppliers, which were subsequently exported to third countries with a 0% VAT rate. The court's ruling underscored the entitlement of businesses to a VAT refund under such circumstances, aligning with the principles outlined in the VAT Directive, a cornerstone of the European Union's VAT system.

However, the court also highlighted a crucial caveat. The right to reclaim VAT is contingent upon the uninterrupted completion of the VAT identification procedure. Should this process be impeded or declined, the company risks forfeiting its taxable payer status, consequently losing the right to claim VAT refunds, irrespective of the bona fide business purposes underpinning the purchases.

At Briddge, we acknowledge the strategic importance of safeguarding your VAT deductibility rights, especially during the pre-active VAT number phase. Our team of seasoned professionals, possessing a wealth of expertise in VAT matters, stands ready to navigate the complexities inherent in VAT refund claims for your business activities and operational purchases. For inquiries or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact us. Your peace of mind is our priority.



Stay up to date

Explore the latest news

From 2024 – C02 Tracking and Reporting of Employee Travel Totals

on February 6, 2024
We would like to inform you regarding a new reporting obligation that will be implemented starting 1 July 2024. If your company employs at least 100 employees in the Netherlands, you will be required to track and report the total number of kilometers your employees travel for work-related purposes annually. This initiative is part of a government plan to monitor and eventually reduce CO2 emissions linked to business travel.
Continue reading

EU Introduces Revised VAT Scheme to Boost SMEs Across Member States

on February 1, 2024
Effective January 1, 2025, the European Union (EU) is implementing a comprehensive overhaul of its Value Added Tax (VAT) scheme, with a primary focus on supporting small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) across all Member States. The new framework introduces key features aimed at standardizing VAT registration thresholds and extending benefits to non-resident EU businesses.
Continue reading